Hume sentenced to one year, probation

By Jon Johnson
Assistant Editor
Published on Wednesday, May 7, 2008 9:13 AM MST

After listening to attorney’s arguments and a passionate plea for justice written by one of the victims, Judge R. Douglas Holt accepted former Thatcher Art teacher Stephen Hume’s guilty plea and sentenced him on Monday to spend one year in the Graham County Jail.

Deputy County Attorney C. Alan Perkins said the case represented a betrayal of the trust and respect associated in a student/teacher relationship.

Hume was initially questioned by the Thatcher Police Department after one of his victims found a camera/video recording device while she was changing into clothes for an art project. Hume would instruct the girls to change in a storage closet where he had crudely set up a surveillance system to record them in a state of undress.

Perkins and Hume’s defense attorney, Wendell Hughes, agreed that the camera system was a poor attempt at voyeurism and that Hume had just begun engaging in that activity.

“The method that he chose to surreptitiously view these girls changing clothes was almost certain to get him caught,” Perkins said.

Hughes made sure to point out the many years of service Hume has performed for his family and the community, including his involvement in the Neighborhood Watch Program and 18 years as a water safety instructor for Safford pools.

“He made a mistake,” Hughes said. “It was a bad mistake. . . Ten minutes can ruin 20 years of work, and that’s basically what happened to him.”

At Hume’s previous change-of-plea hearing, Judge Holt deferred acceptance until sentencing because he was not satisfied with some of Hume’s answers. Holt then ordered Hume to take a lie detector test before moving forward.

Before the test, Hume admitted to authorities that he knew of one more memory card that he had hidden in a file cabinet in his previous office at Thatcher High School.

The card contained another victim in a state of undress, but the victim declined to press charges because Hume was already being prosecuted for the seven other victims.

Holt and Perkins said they were now satisfied that there is no other objectionable material in relation to Hume videotaping his students.

During the sentencing, the mother of one of the victims read a statement the victim had written.

The victim’s statement spoke of painfully reliving the experience every night through nightmares, ridicule by her peers forcing her out of school and being diagnosed with depression. The victim wrote Hume was one of her favorite teachers but ended up an authority figure who took advantage his power over her. It was important to her that Hume be forced to register as a sex offender so others would not be unaware of him.

Hume said he was ashamed and embarrassed for what he did. He apologized to the victims, their families, THS and the community as a whole.

Hughes asked if Hume would be given two days credit for one served for every day he taught the inmates as a trustee.

After initially granting Hughes’ request, Holt rescinded his judgement and said he felt Hume needed to serve the full year to satisfy the demand for punishment.

In addition to one year in jail on one count of attempted voyeurism, Holt sentenced Hume to serve three years of intensive probation upon his release for the six other attempted voyeurism counts and register as a sex offender.

Upon completion of his probation, his probation officer may recommend Hume be removed from the sex offender registration.

Comments

9 comment(s)

    DJ L. former student wrote on Aug 6, 2008 1:53 AM:

    " i loved hume, he was my friend, and teacher. he screwed up, but everybody knew he was a little "dirty minded" he made a mistake that will haunt him for the rest of his life, one year in prison plus probation, is plenty for his actual charges. he didnt touch them, all he did was look. its the same as if he was looking at women on an adult site, you cant get arrested for that. JUST LEAVE HIM ALONE. of course thatcher is smalltown minded, so he will never no peace, isnt that enough! "

    Reddy for Change wrote on May 8, 2008 11:42 AM:

    " Remember these were children, sent to school by their parents whom entrusted them to the school. Since they were children and I doubt he made video merely as an art form, it is called Exploitation of a Minor! That's what the custodian in Phoenix was charged with. It degrades trust between the schools and parents and should be punished to the maximum. "

    reality wrote on May 8, 2008 9:53 AM:

    " Reality is correct. His charges do not require him to register per the Arizona Revised Statutes set forth by the legislature. The Judge in this case used his discretion to make that requirement, and to give him the the year in jail as a term of probation. He also used his discretion to give him sex offender terms and intensive probation even though he was not convicted of a sex offense. "

    Reality wrote on May 8, 2008 9:01 AM:

    " It's true this teacher violated students by taking pictures & looking at them = Voyerism. This is what he was charged with & what he's convicted of. Technically, as per Arizona Revised Statutes IS NOT a sex crime. Look it up. This teacher actually got hammered more than perhaps the average person charged with the same thing. He didn't touch any one, nor did he PHYSICALLY violate them. He has 1 year jail & Probation to follow. If he violates probation, he will go to prison. Those are the facts "

    parent wrote on May 7, 2008 10:08 PM:

    " as a parent look at all the jobs he has had. the swimming pool (where there are young girls) and neighborhood watch (where there are young girls houses) maybe someone should look into this and see if there are more victims. one year is nothing comapred to what these girls will have to live with. "

    peek -a- boo - I -see-you wrote on May 7, 2008 8:58 PM:

    " Hughes must be stupid ! "Ten minutes can ruin 20 years of work"? Let's see - (8) victims,that we know of.Watching it over and over.Do the math,it's not 10 minutes. Oh! and his service to his family and community - 18 yr's as a water safety instructor for Safford pools? That's more videos! Let's not forget the 2 for 1 day served special,that sounds like a HAPPY HOUR special.I can't believe Holt granted that request at one time.Slam him while he's plotting something.Don't wait until you catch him with his pants down.It'll be too late!The damage will be DONE!!! "

    And to think wrote on May 7, 2008 7:51 PM:

    " Mr. Hume isn't even a Mormon. Hey mormon haters, a non-mormon getting off easy. What do you think of that? I guess it isn't just mormons that rule the Gila Valley or get off easy now is it? See, it just happens, and it has nothing to do with religion! "

    Reddy for Change wrote on May 7, 2008 4:52 PM:

    " Obviously those responsible for protecting the children in the Gila Valley are lax in their roles. The same week Hume was arrested, a school custodian in Phoenix was caught placing a cell phone where it could look up girls skirts. He was immediately arrested, as well he should have.

    On the other hand, a teacher is in a position of trust with our children. They should then be held to a higher standard, not lower. I think it is time for some changes in leadership positions throughout the Gila Valley! "

    maybe Im crazy wrote on May 7, 2008 12:33 PM:

    " wow, one year thats it! So you are a person of trust, you betray it by looking at young girls and you get a slap on the hand! Then ask to be removed from the sex offender list? What is this world coming too? Makes me not even want to send my kids out of the house, if you cant trust a teacher who can you trust? "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

Classifieds


Copper Era
1 Wards Canyon
Clifton, AZ 85533
928-865-3162